Addis Herald
  • Home
  • History
  • Africa
  • Travel
  • Music
  • Culture
  • Art

Culture

  • calanderEthiopia: A truly unique African country
  • passionfruit-istanbul-croppedPassionfruit’s Globe-Trotting DJ Mixes Tell Stories Through Disco
  • Ethiopia-HighlandsThe most breathtaking geography in Ethiopia
  • Christmas in Lalibela‘Genna’: Christ’s birthday anniversary, an indispensable part of Ethiopian culture
  • the weekendThe Weeknd’s Next Album Will Be Inspired By BLM Movement, COVID-19 Pandemic

Business

  • siemensEthiopia Signs Deal To Build Phase 1 of $440 Million Assela Wind Farm Project
  • EthiopiaCan agriculture be Ethiopia’s growth engine?
  • Orange-Digital-VenturesGIZ and Orange launch an Orange Digital Center in Ethiopia, the 3rd in Africa and the Middle East region
  • 31342IMF and Ethiopia agree framework for loan deal reviews
  • 11-2-696x446Ethiopian Coffee History: From Chewing to Brewing

Africa

  • jad20210225-culture-nefertiti-akhenaton-592x296-1614265493-e1614766131609Ancient Egypt’s Queen Nefertiti & King Akhenaten finally in a photo
  • 20140208_MAP001_0Africa’s manufacturing puzzle: Evidence from Tanzanian and Ethiopian firms
  • battle of adwa woriorThe Victory of Adwa: A Fresh Perspective
  • shutterstock_pricing-317799113ECA Price Watch points to construction sector as key driver of growth
  • africa-s-pulse-april-2018-780x439China’s poverty alleviation model instructive for Africa: expert
48406461
July 15, 2019

Africa Isn’t Being Re-Colonized

By Noah Smith, Bloomberg

There’s a big difference between military conquest and development with overseas capital and know-how.

A number of African countries appear to be in the early stages of their own industrial revolution, promising to lift hundreds of millions out of grinding poverty. Much of the impetus for this transformation is coming from Chinese investment:

This is how development typically starts.
This is how development typically starts.Photographer: Michelle Cattani/AFP/Getty Images

But when confronted with this news, some well-meaning Westerners — as well as some wary Africans — worry that what’s really happening is a new form of colonialism. This worry especially crops up with respect to China and its large, well-publicized infrastructure projects, but it also sometimes gets applied to independent Chinese-owned factories operating on the continent, or just to foreign investment in general. If foreigners are profiting from Africa’s rise, some reason, that can only mean the continent’s resources are being extracted on unfair terms.

China's Big Move

This concern is natural, given Africa’s tragic recent history of foreign conquest, occupation and exploitation. And in the case of China’s infrastructure projects, the worry may be justified. But privately owned factories in Africa are not a colonial project.

Colonialism involves domination through violence. The many small Chinese entrepreneurs moving to Africa to set up shop do not have the backing of a mighty state or an armada of warships. They are on their own, and as author and development researcher Irene Yuan Sun reports in her book, “The Next Factory of the World: How Chinese Investment Is Reshaping Africa,” these independent capitalists often lose everything they have to fires, crime or other local hazards.

What’s more, Sun’s research shows that these Chinese entrepreneurs generally hire locals. Despite much-publicized cases of Chinese companies importing Chinese workers to Africa, this is the exception rather than the rule. Something like 95% of Chinese manufacturing companies in Africa hire local workers, and 54% hire managers locally, while 73% offer apprenticeships or professional training programs for locals.

Skeptics may believe that Chinese factory owners’ profits, which can run to more than 20% , represent exploitation by foreigners. But because most Chinese entrepreneurs live in Africa near the factories they run, much of that profit gets spent locally, and is thus pumped back into the local economy. Furthermore, although wages are low and factory conditions are often harsh or dangerous — sadly typical for countries in the early stages of industrialization — a profit margin of 20% still means that the bulk of the businesses’ expenditures are flowing to workers and suppliers, many of whom are African.

The profits reaped by these expatriate Chinese entrepreneurs don’t represent colonialist resource exploitation. Instead, they represent the win-win nature of industrialization. Unlike economies based on natural resources, industrial economies are not zero-sum games — they represent the creation of wealth through human ingenuity and labor. Just because Chinese factory owners are winning doesn’t mean African workers are losing.

Of course, in the long run, Africans should and will become owners and capitalists themselves. African managers in Chinese factories will learn the tricks of the trade and then strike out on their own. But for now, foreign investment in African manufacturing looks similar to the early stages of industrialization in China itself. Under Deng Xiaoping and his successors, China threw open the doors to foreign capital, offering itself as a low-cost production platform for foreigners. That was only the first stage, however, as Chinese workers learned from the foreigners and eventually moved up the value chain.

So private Chinese investment in Africa isn’t a form of colonialism, and the Japanese, German, and Indianmultinationals now setting up shop in Africa aren’t colonizers. This is how development works.

But there is one type of Chinese involvement in Africa that does threaten to become something akin to colonialism — Chinese government infrastructure loans. Chinese government banks are lending African governments large amounts of money to build roads, bridges, ports and so on, often secretly. Although some of that infrastructure will be beneficial for African countries, some projects will not recoup their costs. When that happens, small African countries will be left holding the bag, owing money to the mighty Chinese government. China will then hold substantial leverage over its African debtors.

If that’s not old-style colonialism, it’s too close for comfort. African governments should be wary of Chinese state-owned banks offering lavish loans. Instead, they should focus on soliciting private investment in manufacturing industries, while providing infrastructure, education and other public goods on their own. This strategy will ensure that Africa’s road to industrialization is as rapid and smooth as possible without the taint of colonialism.

Source Bloomberg

What’s driving Russia’s interest in Africa? GreenPath taps into Ethiopia’s burgeoning organic popfarming market

Related Posts

jad20210225-culture-nefertiti-akhenaton-592x296-1614265493-e1614766131609

Africa, World

Ancient Egypt’s Queen Nefertiti & King Akhenaten finally in a photo

20140208_MAP001_0

Africa, News

Africa’s manufacturing puzzle: Evidence from Tanzanian and Ethiopian firms

battle of adwa worior

Africa, The Battle of Adwa, The battle of Adwa, World

The Victory of Adwa: A Fresh Perspective

Industrial Parks Development | Ethiopia |

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o-vSnVQfBoo

Africa

  • jad20210225-culture-nefertiti-akhenaton-592x296-1614265493-e1614766131609Ancient Egypt’s Queen Nefertiti & King Akhenaten finally in a photo
  • 20140208_MAP001_0Africa’s manufacturing puzzle: Evidence from Tanzanian and Ethiopian firms
  • battle of adwa woriorThe Victory of Adwa: A Fresh Perspective
  • shutterstock_pricing-317799113ECA Price Watch points to construction sector as key driver of growth
  • africa-s-pulse-april-2018-780x439China’s poverty alleviation model instructive for Africa: expert

Travel

  • Homage to Entoto Park How the Old “Town in the Forest” is turning into a newly flowering tourist hubHomage to Entoto Park How the Old “Town in the Forest” is turning into a newly flowering tourist hub
  • 00ddd3-724x483This Is What It’s Like Trekking the Hottest Place on Earth
  • Screenshot_20200106-034619_GalleryExtreme Ethiopia in pictures
  • Addis-skyline-768x402Enigmatic Ethiopia: Africa’s (still) hidden jewel in the crown?
  • 929-1024x524-488x250Ethiopia’s Tourism sector is on the rise

Culture

  • calanderEthiopia: A truly unique African country
  • passionfruit-istanbul-croppedPassionfruit’s Globe-Trotting DJ Mixes Tell Stories Through Disco
  • Ethiopia-HighlandsThe most breathtaking geography in Ethiopia
  • Christmas in Lalibela‘Genna’: Christ’s birthday anniversary, an indispensable part of Ethiopian culture
  • the weekendThe Weeknd’s Next Album Will Be Inspired By BLM Movement, COVID-19 Pandemic

Business

  • siemensEthiopia Signs Deal To Build Phase 1 of $440 Million Assela Wind Farm Project
  • EthiopiaCan agriculture be Ethiopia’s growth engine?
  • Orange-Digital-VenturesGIZ and Orange launch an Orange Digital Center in Ethiopia, the 3rd in Africa and the Middle East region
  • 31342IMF and Ethiopia agree framework for loan deal reviews
  • 11-2-696x446Ethiopian Coffee History: From Chewing to Brewing

RSS Allfrica.com News feed

  • Africa: Covid-19 Pandemic Sparked Year of Rights Crises
  • Africa: Meet Seven Women Saving the Planet
  • Africa: Over 4 Million Vaccinated Against Covid-19 Across Continent
  • Africa: Online Scammers Rake in Millions From Sale of Covid-19 'Vaccines'
  • Africa: Africa's Urban Risk and Resilience!
  • Africa: Why Community Engagement is Critical in Fight Against Malaria
  • Africa: Key Actors Commit to Smart Nutrition, Ensuring Faster Progress to Ending Malnutrition
  • Africa: Humanitarian Needs Grow in Tigray Region
  • Africa: Why Some Africans Are Wary of the Covid-19 Vaccine
  • Africa: Covid Restrictions Chipping Away At Civil Liberties
  • Abijitta-Shalla National Park
  • Alatish Ethiopian National Park
  • Awash National Park
  • Babille Elephant Sanctuary
  • Bahir Dar Blue Nile Millennium Park
  • Bale National Park; Ethiopia’s lesser-known Treasure
  • Bale Mountains National Park
  • Borena-Sayint National Park
  • Chebera Churchura National Park
  • Dati Wolel National park
  • Gambella National Park
  • Gambella National Park 2
  • Kafta-Sheraro National Park
  • Mago National Park
  • Maze National Park
  • Nechisar National Park, Ethiopia
  • Omo National Park 
  • The Semien Mountains
  • Yabello National Park
  • Yangudi Rassa National Park
© Addis Herald 2021
  • Contact us
en English
af Afrikaansam Amharicar Arabiczh-CN Chinese (Simplified)en Englishfr Frenchde Germanel Greekhi Hindiit Italianja Japaneseko Koreanla Latinru Russianes Spanishsu Sudanesesw Swahilisv Swedish