Addis Herald
  • Home
  • History
  • Africa
  • Travel
  • Music
  • Culture
  • Art

Culture

  • BF1CAA6E-18B6-422A-B62B-16E90D1E0AD5Ethiopian Food as Divine Blessing
  • Skylight-hotel-New-Year-719-Copy-Copy-2-Copy-1How Perfect Is Ethiopian Calander? The Answer Lies On The Seventh Day Of Pagume ‘Aqede’
  • 581FB89E-5B1B-42C7-9A4C-C6658A75C52FEight must-try dishes for Ethiopian New Year in the UAE
  • ED93F3AC-74DA-413B-9810-5B803E7A915FLet this 99-year-old nun be your introduction to Ethio-jazz
  • E00B6DCF-A08A-4223-8597-6734E7355A12Dagmawi Lalibela: The Newest Rock-hewn churches in Ethiopia

Business

  • 49694448-951E-40EB-892F-0DC7CA997B7FWe want to help African airlines recover as we develop region’s aviation industry
  • 4423A6A8-9118-4001-A568-29491271B89BEthiopian Airline Expect To Double Its Fleet And Network By 2035
  • 338F47E9-4A86-4C4F-B56B-479A33A38BDBEthiopian To Fly 3x Daily To Johannesburg and Daily To South American Cities
  • 72B160A7-3A4E-49D6-984C-8AAFB0B7F710Ethiopia and Somalia are Scripting History With a Joint Infrastructure Project
  • 6A6D21B7-BE07-41C3-BC38-D28986C21290Ethiopian Airlines emerges core investor in Nigeria Air with 49% shareholding

Africa

  • Flag-map_of_Algeria.svgAlgeria
  • C440468B-373F-4269-A304-F8C6C8601C31Is Al-Shabab a UN puppet, latest developments strongly suggest so
  • 53BFAF0F-3573-48A6-A062-B650F6D96118Did You Know 14 Teams With Players Of African Origins In 2022 World Cup
  • 45FE9518-D50A-4265-874F-6BB435842EB7Ten key Points That African Leaders Committed To Industrialize The Continent
  • 46E10F33-E3C8-4F7A-9B31-A3204390FC3CNCBA eyes deals for M-Shwari into DRC, Ethiopia
AMRTQDYWJYKQXKK4AFFLEG6QHY
October 25, 2019

Why are there no black Nobel laureates in science?

popular Science By Grace Wade

Stephen B. Thomas and Carol Espy-Wilson lead the Advancing Faculty Diversity training program at the University of Maryland, College Park. Thomas experienced isolating experiences in his PhD program and has since worked to provide better mentoring resources for minority students.University Maryland Center for Health Equity

Stephen B. Thomas will never forget the day a senior faculty member threw his thesis into a trash can.

As one of the few black men in the doctorate program at Southern Illinois University, the experience was quite traumatic.

“He held up my draft, pulled his waste basket from under his desk, and dropped my thesis in the trash with a bang,” says Thomas, now a public health professor at the University of Maryland College Park. “Only later did I find the words to describe his type: He was a tormentor, not a mentor.”

For black Americans in the fields of science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM), lack of moral and financial support is typical. Centuries of slavery and segregation have limited their communities from economic and educational opportunities; today, only 12.6 percent of STEM-degree holders in the U.S. are black—and that’s just at the undergraduate level. The field grows even narrower at higher levels of research, where experts are more likely to be rewarded for their work.ADVERTISEMENT / ADVERTISE WITH US

The pattern is painfully obvious in the Nobel Prizes for Medicine or Physiology, Physics, and Chemistry, which have seen no black laureates in their 61-year history. But the lack of diversity in the Assembly’s picks is symptomatic of much deeper inequities in American education.

A lopsided system from Pre-K to college

The journey of becoming a Nobel Laureate starts at a young age. According to Lorelle Espinosa, the vice president for research at the American Council on Education, a nonprofit that helps steer public policy, early education shapes children’s language, literacy, and math development, setting them up for success later on in their academic career.

But low-income black families often can’t send their kids to preschool due to the high costs of attendance. What’s more, the conventional funding structure for public schools favors wealthy, white populations, limiting black youth’s access to STEM lab equipment, advanced placement courses, and extracurriculars.

“It is well known that if you are not on track in terms of math and science by about middle school (or some research suggests even earlier than that), you don’t have a high likelihood of getting to your senior year of high school,” Espinosa says.

Students who defy odds to graduate and attend college then have to work around the biases of predominantly white faculty. In 2016, only 3.8 percent of full-time, tenured professors at universities were black. These staffers act as role models for students, taking them on as advisees, often choosing students with similar backgrounds and experiences as them.

“These kinds of attitudes work against students of color, even if the faculty isn’t full aware it’s happening,” Espinosa explains. “We need the white faculty body to advocate and mentor black students. It’s not like you have to be black to mentor a black student.”

The STEM climate is also notorious for its “weed-out culture.” Patchy academic guidance, along with overly rigorous course material, encourages students to drop out at staggering rates. A study on 5,600 college kids in 2004 showed that 26 percent of black students left their STEM majors before graduation, compared to just 13 percent of their white peers. Data from other fields such as business didn’t show a major racial discrepancy.

“If you are a minority student who already may feel like you do not belong, this culture can be quite traumatic,” Thomas says. In the decades since his thesis confrontation, he’s helped direct a nation-wide project that trains senior faculty to act as mentors for underrepresented minorities in STEM. “Little slights that people of color face every single day convince them that people like them can’t do math, even if they are getting a 4.0 average,” Thomas adds.

Those who do earn their bachelors in STEM are more likely to opt out of post-graduate education—all but a must for Nobel laureates—due to financial burdens. Black undergraduate students leave college with a higher debt burden than any other racial group, Espinosa says, largely because the wealth gap forces them to take out more loans for tuition. If they can afford grad school, either by applying for additional loans or competing for stipends, they might land at a flexible two-year program or community college—not the institutions typically associated with Nobel prize.

“At every turn along the pathway to a doctorate in STEM, these structural barriers arise,” Espinosa says. “I think that is why we aren’t seeing a black Nobel Laureate in STEM.”

The Nobel Prize medal
The Nobel Prize has overlooked black scientists who’ve helped revolutionize blood transfusions and pharmaceuticals.Bernard Clark/Queens University

The problem with “hard sciences”

Outside of the classroom, black scientists encounter hurdles when it comes to funding their research proposals. A 2011 study led by economist Donna Ginther of the University of Kansas found that white applicants were much more likely to get grants from National Institute of Health (NIH) than others. A study published this month in Science Advances found a possible explanation for the disparities in funding proposals: Black applicants are more likely to come up with projects on health disparities, adolescent health, and fertility—practical applications to address crises that disproportionately affect black communities in the U.S. The NIH’s funding system, however, favors “basic sciences” such as physics, chemistry, and biology—the same fields lionized by the Nobel Prize.

“The very man who actually implemented the inoculation to prevent polio on a mass scale is not a Nobel Prize winner,” Thomas says, referring to the 1954 controversy where John Enders, Thomas Weller, and Frederick Robbins were recognized for their discovery to grow poliovirus in cultures, even though it was Jonas Salk who created the vaccine. “A lot of people say the reason Salk did not get a Nobel Prize was because his work was applied science,” Thomas explains.

If the Nobel Assembly broadened its scope to topics like biology, robotics, and computer science, it could find a more diverse pool of laureates. But as the selection process stands, it serves as yet another barrier for the black scientist.

Eyes on the prize

Of course, racial inequalities in the American education system are only part of the Nobel’s white-man woes. The prize is international, which means that black students in other parts of the world must be facing similar lags and obstacles.

Thomas also points out that STEM is diversifying as a whole, so the question remains whether the Assembly can objectively evaluate the science of non-white experts. In the past the Nobel has failed to recognize black scientists like Charles Drew, “the father of blood banks,” and Percy Lavon Julian, a chemist who pioneered the synthesis of plant-based medicines, despite their big, celebrated ideas.

Source popular Science

“Intelligence knows no color; it does not even know economic status,” Thomas says. “What we need to figure out is how to nurture that intelligence, how to ensure that the innate curiosity is not snuffed out early in the educational experience, when there are moments of being told that ‘people like us don’t like math.’ ”Sponsored LinksYou May Like

Putin: Trade with African countries to double over the next four to five years The coming election may unlikely to be a strictly top-down nationwide affair like the past five polls.

Related Posts

Flag-map_of_Algeria.svg

Africa, African countries, World

Algeria

C440468B-373F-4269-A304-F8C6C8601C31

Africa, Headlines

Is Al-Shabab a UN puppet, latest developments strongly suggest so

53BFAF0F-3573-48A6-A062-B650F6D96118

Africa, Sport

Did You Know 14 Teams With Players Of African Origins In 2022 World Cup

4 kilo

https://youtu.be/FgCCCrGK8wE

እናትዋ ጎንደር

https://youtu.be/RRqTpYYb7d4

Travel

  • Ethiopia has Over 10,000 Megalithic Monuments dating Back to the 1st CenturyEthiopia has Over 10,000 Megalithic Monuments Dating Back to the 1st Century
  • ethiopia_ethiopian_wolf_35Brilliant Ethiopia: The Unique Wonder
  • F6BD7E94-BC77-4B3E-B905-7B140F12F5FDKenya Had an Elephant ‘Baby Boom’ — and Now You Can Adopt One
  • Addis_herald_omo_3910 Main Tourist Attractions Places in Africa
  • Homage to Entoto Park How the Old “Town in the Forest” is turning into a newly flowering tourist hubHomage to Entoto Park How the Old “Town in the Forest” is turning into a newly flowering tourist hub

Africa

  • Flag-map_of_Algeria.svgAlgeria
  • C440468B-373F-4269-A304-F8C6C8601C31Is Al-Shabab a UN puppet, latest developments strongly suggest so
  • 53BFAF0F-3573-48A6-A062-B650F6D96118Did You Know 14 Teams With Players Of African Origins In 2022 World Cup
  • 45FE9518-D50A-4265-874F-6BB435842EB7Ten key Points That African Leaders Committed To Industrialize The Continent
  • 46E10F33-E3C8-4F7A-9B31-A3204390FC3CNCBA eyes deals for M-Shwari into DRC, Ethiopia

Culture

  • BF1CAA6E-18B6-422A-B62B-16E90D1E0AD5Ethiopian Food as Divine Blessing
  • Skylight-hotel-New-Year-719-Copy-Copy-2-Copy-1How Perfect Is Ethiopian Calander? The Answer Lies On The Seventh Day Of Pagume ‘Aqede’
  • 581FB89E-5B1B-42C7-9A4C-C6658A75C52FEight must-try dishes for Ethiopian New Year in the UAE
  • ED93F3AC-74DA-413B-9810-5B803E7A915FLet this 99-year-old nun be your introduction to Ethio-jazz
  • E00B6DCF-A08A-4223-8597-6734E7355A12Dagmawi Lalibela: The Newest Rock-hewn churches in Ethiopia

Business

  • 49694448-951E-40EB-892F-0DC7CA997B7FWe want to help African airlines recover as we develop region’s aviation industry
  • 4423A6A8-9118-4001-A568-29491271B89BEthiopian Airline Expect To Double Its Fleet And Network By 2035
  • 338F47E9-4A86-4C4F-B56B-479A33A38BDBEthiopian To Fly 3x Daily To Johannesburg and Daily To South American Cities
  • 72B160A7-3A4E-49D6-984C-8AAFB0B7F710Ethiopia and Somalia are Scripting History With a Joint Infrastructure Project
  • 6A6D21B7-BE07-41C3-BC38-D28986C21290Ethiopian Airlines emerges core investor in Nigeria Air with 49% shareholding

RSS Allfrica.com News feed

  • Africa: Senegal Star Sy Named CHAN 2022 Best Goalkeeper
  • Africa: L'algérino, Ckay, Zaho Ignite CHAN 2022 Closing Ceremony
  • Africa: Algeria's Mahious Scoops CHAN 2022 Golden Boot Award
  • Africa: Senegal Win Penalty Shootout Against Algeria to Become CHAN Champions
  • Africa: Algeria's Mrezigue Named TotalEnergies CHAN 2022 Best Player
  • Africa: Dax Elated With Madagascar Presidential Phone Call
  • Africa: Niger Proud of CHAN Campaign Despite Loss
  • Africa: Rakotondrabe Over the Moon Following CHAN Bronze
  • Africa: Madagascar Beat Niger to Clinch TotalEnergies CHAN Third Place
  • Africa: World Will Miss Target of Ending FGM By 2030 Without Urgent Action - Including From Men and Boys
  • Abijitta-Shalla National Park
  • Alatish Ethiopian National Park
  • Awash National Park
  • Babille Elephant Sanctuary
  • Bahir Dar Blue Nile Millennium Park
  • Bale National Park; Ethiopia’s lesser-known Treasure
  • Bale Mountains National Park
  • Borena-Sayint National Park
  • Chebera Churchura National Park
  • Dati Wolel National park
  • Gambella National Park
  • Gambella National Park 2
  • Kafta-Sheraro National Park
  • Mago National Park
  • Maze National Park
  • Nechisar National Park, Ethiopia
  • Omo National Park 
  • The Semien Mountains
  • Yabello National Park
  • Yangudi Rassa National Park
© Addis Herald 2023
  • Contact us
en English
am Amharicar Arabiczh-CN Chinese (Simplified)en Englishfr Frenchde Germanel Greekhi Hindiit Italianja Japaneseko Koreanla Latinru Russianes Spanishsu Sudanesesw Swahilisv Swedish